wouldit.work

SaaS

Atrium: $75.5M to rebuild the law firm with software, shut down after three years

Justin Kan's Atrium combined legal software with in-house lawyers for startups. It raised $75.5 million, pivoted away from its lawyers in January 2020 and shut down weeks later, laying off just over 100 people.

Product
Atrium
Founder
Justin Kan
Launched
2017
Model
Subscription packages of software plus legal work

Published · 2 min read · 2 sources

Key takeaways

  • Atrium raised $75.5 million, with Andreessen Horowitz leading its Series B, and shut down in March 2020, laying off just over 100 employees.
  • In January 2020 it laid off most of its in-house lawyers to become more of a pure software company; Kan said it was tough to regain momentum after that.
  • Kan: Atrium and similar companies 'did not figure out how to make a dent in operational efficiency.'

What it is

Atrium built software for startups to handle fundraising, hiring, acquisitions and work with their legal team, and offered in-house lawyers too (TechCrunch). The idea was that the software would make its lawyers more efficient than a traditional firm (TechCrunch).

Timeline

  • 2017: Atrium is founded (TechCrunch).
  • April 2019: co-founder and managing partner Augie Rakow leaves the company (LawSites).
  • January 2020: Atrium lets go of most of its legal staff and says it will pivot to "building a professional services network dedicated to founders" (LawSites).
  • 3 March 2020: Kan tells TechCrunch Atrium is shutting down. It lays off all its employees, just over 100, and will return some of its $75.5 million in funding to investors, including Series B lead Andreessen Horowitz (TechCrunch).
  • After the shutdown: a separate Atrium law firm continues under partners Michel Narganes and Matthew Melville (TechCrunch).

Why it worked

  • A founder with a track record. Kan had previously founded Justin.tv, which became Twitch and sold to Amazon for $970 million (TechCrunch).
  • Founder-led marketing. Atrium generated leads by hosting fundraising workshops for startups starring Kan (TechCrunch).
  • Pricing that broke from the billable hour. It sold subscription packages, with add-on fees for big deals like acquisitions (TechCrunch).

What to learn

  1. Prove the efficiency gain before scaling the expensive part. Eliminating busywork for lawyers "didn't materialize into bountiful profits", while keeping lawyers on staff "proved costly" (TechCrunch).
  2. A pivot can cost trust. Some customers said the January change "felt chaotic and left them unsure of their legal representation" (TechCrunch).
  3. Selling software to entrenched professionals is slow. Lawyers with set processes may not find new workflows "worth the thrash" (TechCrunch).

Risks and what didn't work

  • The full-stack model. "A lot of these companies, Atrium included, did not figure out how to make a dent in operational efficiency," Kan said (TechCrunch).
  • Momentum after the pivot. Kan said it was tough to regain momentum after laying off the in-house lawyers (TechCrunch).
  • Leadership churn. A co-founder left less than a year before the shutdown (LawSites).
  • Responsibility. Kan wrote: "Things didn't work out as planned and that is my responsibility" (TechCrunch).

FAQ

Short answers drawn from the sections above.

What is Atrium?

Atrium built software for startups to handle fundraising, hiring, acquisitions and work with their legal team, and offered in-house lawyers too (TechCrunch). The idea was that the software would make its lawyers more efficient than a traditional firm (TechCrunch).

Why did Atrium work?

  • A founder with a track record. Kan had previously founded Justin.tv, which became Twitch and sold to Amazon for $970 million (TechCrunch).
  • Founder-led marketing. Atrium generated leads by hosting fundraising workshops for startups starring Kan (TechCrunch).
  • Pricing that broke from the billable hour. It sold subscription packages, with add-on fees for big deals like acquisitions (TechCrunch).

What can indie builders learn from Atrium?

  1. Prove the efficiency gain before scaling the expensive part. Eliminating busywork for lawyers "didn't materialize into bountiful profits", while keeping lawyers on staff "proved costly" (TechCrunch).
  2. A pivot can cost trust. Some customers said the January change "felt chaotic and left them unsure of their legal representation" (TechCrunch).
  3. Selling software to entrenched professionals is slow. Lawyers with set processes may not find new workflows "worth the thrash" (TechCrunch).

What didn't work for Atrium, and what are the risks?

  • The full-stack model. "A lot of these companies, Atrium included, did not figure out how to make a dent in operational efficiency," Kan said (TechCrunch).
  • Momentum after the pivot. Kan said it was tough to regain momentum after laying off the in-house lawyers (TechCrunch).
  • Leadership churn. A co-founder left less than a year before the shutdown (LawSites).
  • Responsibility. Kan wrote: "Things didn't work out as planned and that is my responsibility" (TechCrunch).

Sources

Every link cited above, in order of first use.

  1. 1.TechCrunch (techcrunch.com)
  2. 2.LawSites (lawnext.com)

Related case studies

More in SaaS →