wouldit.work

Developer tools

Heroku: Salesforce paid $212 million, then ended the free tier

Orion Henry, James Lindenbaum, and Adam Wiggins built a Ruby platform-as-a-service that Salesforce acquired in 2010 for about $212 million in cash. In 2022 Heroku shut down its free plans, citing fraud and abuse, and pushed hobbyists toward paid tiers.

Product
Heroku
Founder
Orion Henry, James Lindenbaum, and Adam Wiggins
Launched
2007
Model
Paid dynos and data add-ons; a long-running free tier was removed in 2022

Published · 3 min read · 8 sources

Key takeaways

  • Heroku was founded in 2007 and, according to TechCrunch, went through Y Combinator in 2008 and had raised only $13 million before the sale.
  • On 8 December 2010 Salesforce announced a deal to buy Heroku for approximately $212 million in cash, net of cash acquired. The acquisition closed on 3 January 2011.
  • On 25 August 2022 Heroku said it would stop offering free plans on 28 November 2022, blaming 'fraud and abuse.' Free dynos were converted to Eco plans and scaled to zero; hobby-dev databases in personal accounts were queued for deletion.

What it is

Heroku is a platform-as-a-service for deploying and running web apps. Salesforce's completion announcement said it was "founded in 2007 by Orion Henry, James Lindenbaum and Adam Wiggins, with the goal of creating a platform-as-a-service that would make deploying, managing and scaling next-generation web applications as easy as writing them" (Salesforce). It began as a Ruby platform and later added other languages. Salesforce still operates the product.

Timeline

  • 2007–2008: The company was founded in 2007. TechCrunch wrote that it "was initially provided with seed funding through Y Combinator back in 2008" and, by the time of the sale, "has raised only $13 million in funding" (Salesforce; TechCrunch).
  • December 8, 2010: Salesforce announced a definitive agreement to acquire Heroku "for approximately $212 million in cash, net of cash acquired." TechCrunch, matching the press release, added that Salesforce would grant restricted stock and units "with a value of approximately $27 million to Heroku employees, and commits to paying approximately $10 million in cash for unvested Heroku shares." The company said Heroku then powered "more than 105,000" apps. Then-CEO Byron Sebastian said, "Together, we will provide the best place to run and deploy Cloud 2 apps." Salesforce's Form 8-K described the same cash figure as "currently estimated to be approximately $212 million in the aggregate, net of cash acquired, subject to adjustment" (Salesforce; TechCrunch; SEC).
  • January 3, 2011: Salesforce said it had completed the acquisition. The completion release put the app count at "more than 110,000" and said Heroku then had "about 30 employees" (Salesforce).
  • August 25, 2022: General manager Bob Wise announced that Heroku would "phase out" free plans for dynos, Postgres, and Redis, and delete accounts "inactive for over a year," starting October 26, 2022, with free product plans ending November 28, 2022. "Our product, engineering, and security teams are spending an extraordinary amount of effort to manage fraud and abuse of the Heroku free product plans," he wrote. The post listed low-cost replacements starting at $7/month for dynos, $15/month for Redis, and $9/month for Postgres (Heroku). TechCrunch noted that the change came months after a GitHub-account incident and that Heroku's website then claimed the platform had "been used to develop 13 million apps to date" (a contemporaneous company claim) (TechCrunch).
  • November 28, 2022: A Heroku changelog confirmed that free dynos, hobby-dev Postgres, and hobby-dev Redis were "no longer available." Existing free dynos were converted to Eco dynos "and scaling them to 0." Hobby-dev databases in personal and team accounts were "queuing… for deletion" (Heroku).

Why it worked (for a long time)

  • It removed the server chore. The acquisition materials pitched a workflow "designed to mirror how developers work," with no virtual machines to manage (Salesforce).
  • A small, loved tool can be a strategic buy. Salesforce paid a large multiple of the $13 million TechCrunch said Heroku had raised, to reach Ruby developers (TechCrunch).
  • A free tier taught a generation of developers the product, which is why its removal was so visible (Heroku; TechCrunch).

What to learn

  1. "We'll keep making this easy" is easier to promise at the moment of a sale than a decade later, when the parent company is focused on paying customers (Heroku).
  2. A free plan is a product decision and a security surface. Heroku's stated reason for ending it was fraud and abuse, not a lack of users (Heroku).
  3. If your staging environment or side project lives on a free database, export it before the deletion date. Hobby-dev databases were queued for deletion, not merely scaled down (Heroku).
  4. Competitors show up when a default tool gets more expensive. TechCrunch pointed to Railway, Render, Fly.io, and others in the same story (TechCrunch).

Risks and what didn't work

  • Platform risk arrived as a pricing change, not a shutdown. Heroku still exists, but the free on-ramp that defined it for many indie developers does not (Heroku).
  • The $212 million cash figure was an estimate subject to closing adjustments, as the 8-K itself said.
  • The "13 million apps" figure is a 2022 website claim relayed by TechCrunch, not a number re-checked on the homepage for this article (TechCrunch).
  • The 2022 low-cost prices in Wise's post may have changed since (Heroku).

FAQ

Short answers drawn from the sections above.

What is Heroku?

Heroku is a platform-as-a-service for deploying and running web apps. Salesforce's completion announcement said it was "founded in 2007 by Orion Henry, James Lindenbaum and Adam Wiggins, with the goal of creating a platform-as-a-service that would make deploying, managing and scaling next-generation web applications as easy as writing them" (Salesforce). It began as a Ruby platform and later added other languages. Salesforce still operates the product.

Why did Heroku work?

  • It removed the server chore. The acquisition materials pitched a workflow "designed to mirror how developers work," with no virtual machines to manage (Salesforce).
  • A small, loved tool can be a strategic buy. Salesforce paid a large multiple of the $13 million TechCrunch said Heroku had raised, to reach Ruby developers (TechCrunch).
  • A free tier taught a generation of developers the product, which is why its removal was so visible (Heroku; TechCrunch).

What can indie builders learn from Heroku?

  1. "We'll keep making this easy" is easier to promise at the moment of a sale than a decade later, when the parent company is focused on paying customers (Heroku).
  2. A free plan is a product decision and a security surface. Heroku's stated reason for ending it was fraud and abuse, not a lack of users (Heroku).
  3. If your staging environment or side project lives on a free database, export it before the deletion date. Hobby-dev databases were queued for deletion, not merely scaled down (Heroku).
  4. Competitors show up when a default tool gets more expensive. TechCrunch pointed to Railway, Render, Fly.io, and others in the same story (TechCrunch).

What didn't work for Heroku, and what are the risks?

  • Platform risk arrived as a pricing change, not a shutdown. Heroku still exists, but the free on-ramp that defined it for many indie developers does not (Heroku).
  • The $212 million cash figure was an estimate subject to closing adjustments, as the 8-K itself said.
  • The "13 million apps" figure is a 2022 website claim relayed by TechCrunch, not a number re-checked on the homepage for this article (TechCrunch).
  • The 2022 low-cost prices in Wise's post may have changed since (Heroku).

Sources

Every link cited above, in order of first use.

  1. 1.Heroku (heroku.com)
  2. 2.Salesforce (salesforce.com)
  3. 3.TechCrunch (techcrunch.com)
  4. 4.Salesforce (salesforce.com)
  5. 5.SEC (sec.gov)
  6. 6.$7 (heroku.com)
  7. 7.TechCrunch (techcrunch.com)
  8. 8.Heroku (devcenter.heroku.com)

Related case studies

More in Developer tools →