wouldit.work

Consumer apps

HEY: tens of thousands of paying customers in year one

Jason Fried and David Heinemeier Hansson launched HEY in June 2020 as a $99-a-year email service with no ads and no IMAP. By the first anniversary they said they had tens of thousands of paying customers.

Product
HEY
Founder
Jason Fried and David Heinemeier Hansson (37signals)
Launched
2020-06
Model
Paid subscription (no free tier after a trial)

Published · 2 min read · 4 sources

Key takeaways

  • 37signals launched HEY on June 16, 2020 as a paid email service, priced at $99 a year after a 14-day trial.
  • At launch it had a waitlist of more than 50,000 people and refused IMAP, so HEY only works in its own apps.
  • By February and June 2021 the founders said they had tens of thousands of paying customers, the fastest start of any 37signals product.

What it is

HEY is a paid email service from 37signals, the company behind Basecamp, designed around screening inbound mail, separating newsletters and receipts, and giving people tools such as "Reply Later" and a 14-day trial (TechCrunch). It was created by Jason Fried and David Heinemeier Hansson after the company had previously committed to focusing on Basecamp alone (Jason Fried).

Timeline

  • June 16, 2020: HEY launched with a 37-minute video tour and a waitlist. TechCrunch reported pricing of $99 a year for 100GB of storage after a 14-day trial, and a waitlist of more than 50,000 people. The product was not end-to-end encrypted and did not support IMAP or POP (TechCrunch).
  • On IMAP: Hansson wrote, "Our changes to email required the vertical integration we've done. HEY will only ever work with its own apps" (TechCrunch).
  • February 24, 2021: Hansson wrote that HEY had "already signed up many tens of thousands of paying customers" and had become "the fastest growing product we've ever launched" (DHH). He described the effective price as $8.25/month.
  • June 16, 2021: On the first anniversary, Fried wrote that HEY had "tens of thousands of paying customers," that HEY for Domains had launched for small businesses, and that 37signals is "a company entirely funded by customer revenues" (Jason Fried). He also alluded to "the HEY vs. Apple saga."

Why it worked

  • They charged money from day one. "For two decades, we've operated on a simpler model at Basecamp: Monetize by charging money. That's it. That's the business plan. HEY is no different" (DHH).
  • Independence let them ship a weird product. Fried wrote that they did not have to ask a board or a VC, after previously renaming the company around Basecamp alone (Jason Fried).
  • The workflow was not a thin MVP. TechCrunch described features such as Reply Later and Focus & Reply, plus other organization tools at launch, rather than a minimal webmail clone (TechCrunch).

What to learn

  1. A paid consumer product can work if the alternative is ads, data mining, or a service that might shut down. That was Hansson's explicit pitch (DHH).
  2. Past failures are not always permanent. Basecamp's earlier consumer product, Backpack, was "the hardest $5/month" they had ever worked for; Hansson still backed Fried's idea to sell HEY to individuals.
  3. Vertical integration is a trade: refusing IMAP made HEY's model possible and also locked customers into HEY's apps (TechCrunch).
  4. Founder-led launch content (a long demo, a public waitlist, a clear price) can replace a traditional free tier (Jason Fried, TechCrunch).

Risks and what didn't work

  • Lock-in. No IMAP or POP means leaving HEY is harder than leaving a standard mailbox, by design (TechCrunch).
  • Not end-to-end encrypted. TechCrunch noted that 37signals holds the keys, while promising not to mine the inbox (TechCrunch).
  • Consumer support is expensive. Hansson's Backpack story included a customer calling him at 2am about a price rise, which is why he was wary of consumer email in the first place (DHH).
  • No later public revenue figure in the sources used here. "Tens of thousands of paying customers" is a founder-reported range from 2021, not a current audited number.

FAQ

Short answers drawn from the sections above.

What is HEY?

HEY is a paid email service from 37signals, the company behind Basecamp, designed around screening inbound mail, separating newsletters and receipts, and giving people tools such as "Reply Later" and a 14-day trial (TechCrunch). It was created by Jason Fried and David Heinemeier Hansson after the company had previously committed to focusing on Basecamp alone (Jason Fried).

Why did HEY work?

  • They charged money from day one. "For two decades, we've operated on a simpler model at Basecamp: Monetize by charging money. That's it. That's the business plan. HEY is no different" (DHH).
  • Independence let them ship a weird product. Fried wrote that they did not have to ask a board or a VC, after previously renaming the company around Basecamp alone (Jason Fried).
  • The workflow was not a thin MVP. TechCrunch described features such as Reply Later and Focus & Reply, plus other organization tools at launch, rather than a minimal webmail clone (TechCrunch).

What can indie builders learn from HEY?

  1. A paid consumer product can work if the alternative is ads, data mining, or a service that might shut down. That was Hansson's explicit pitch (DHH).
  2. Past failures are not always permanent. Basecamp's earlier consumer product, Backpack, was "the hardest $5/month" they had ever worked for; Hansson still backed Fried's idea to sell HEY to individuals.
  3. Vertical integration is a trade: refusing IMAP made HEY's model possible and also locked customers into HEY's apps (TechCrunch).
  4. Founder-led launch content (a long demo, a public waitlist, a clear price) can replace a traditional free tier (Jason Fried, TechCrunch).

What didn't work for HEY, and what are the risks?

  • Lock-in. No IMAP or POP means leaving HEY is harder than leaving a standard mailbox, by design (TechCrunch).
  • Not end-to-end encrypted. TechCrunch noted that 37signals holds the keys, while promising not to mine the inbox (TechCrunch).
  • Consumer support is expensive. Hansson's Backpack story included a customer calling him at 2am about a price rise, which is why he was wary of consumer email in the first place (DHH).
  • No later public revenue figure in the sources used here. "Tens of thousands of paying customers" is a founder-reported range from 2021, not a current audited number.

Sources

Every link cited above, in order of first use.

  1. 1.HEY (hey.com)
  2. 2.TechCrunch (techcrunch.com)
  3. 3.Jason Fried (world.hey.com)
  4. 4.DHH (world.hey.com)

Related case studies

More in Consumer apps →