The Messenger: $50 million in, about $3 million in revenue, shut down in eight months
Jimmy Finkelstein launched The Messenger in May 2023 with $50 million. Axios later reported that the news site brought in about $3 million in 2023 revenue, lost tens of millions of dollars, and shut down on 31 January 2024.
- Product
- The Messenger
- Founder
- Jimmy Finkelstein
- Launched
- 2023-05
- Model
- Digital news site supported by advertising; shut down in January 2024
Published · 3 min read · 2 sources
Key takeaways
- Finkelstein launched The Messenger in May 2023 with $50 million, two years after selling The Hill to Nexstar for $130 million, according to Axios.
- Axios, citing financial documents, wrote that the company brought in around $3 million in revenue in 2023, was losing tens of millions of dollars, and had originally projected $100 million in 2024 revenue.
- The site shut down on 31 January 2024 after Finkelstein failed to raise the additional money needed to keep it going. Employees let go at the end received no severance.
What it is
The Messenger was a digital news startup founded by Jimmy Finkelstein. Axios wrote that he launched it in 2023, "two years after he sold The Hill — a Beltway-based print and digital publication co-founded by Finkelstein's father in 1994 — to Nexstar for $130 million" (Axios).
Timeline
- May 2023: The Messenger launched with $50 million in funding, according to Axios. Finkelstein later told Axios the company "raised $50 million ahead of its launch last year" (Axios; Axios).
- 2023 operations: Axios reported that the company "hired 300 people across a few short months and paid them above market wage," and that it "sold mostly automated digital ads at scale" (Axios). In a later interview, Finkelstein said salaries accounted for 82% of expenditures and that he had hired "far less than the 500+ people he originally budgeted for" (Axios).
- January 2024: Axios wrote that the company cut two dozen people earlier in the month, with severance, "when it became clear that it was close to running out of cash" (Axios).
- January 31, 2024: Axios reported that The Messenger would shut down after Finkelstein "came close to raising the cash necessary to keep the business afloat for several more months" but "ultimately failed to close a deal." Citing financial documents it had seen, Axios wrote that the company "only brought in around $3 million in revenue last year," "was losing tens of millions of dollars," and "originally projected $100 million in revenue for 2024." In a staff memo, Finkelstein blamed "economic headwinds facing the media industry" and said, "Unfortunately, as a new company, we encountered even more significant challenges than others and could not survive those headwinds." Axios reported that employees were not offered severance, and that the website was shut down shortly after the announcement (Axios).
- February 13, 2024: In an interview with Axios, Finkelstein said, "I have absolute confidence that by August we would have been profitable. If we raised the $20 million, we would have been absolutely profitable." Axios wrote that 2024 projections had already been cut to "more than $60 million," down from $100 million the previous spring and $75 million in December. Finkelstein also said a last-minute sale to the Los Angeles Times "fell apart the day he decided to shutter the site" (Axios).
Why it worked (for a while)
- The founder had already sold a political-news business. The Hill sale to Nexstar for $130 million made it possible to raise a large seed and hire quickly (Axios).
- The site did get traffic at the end. Finkelstein cited Google Analytics figures, reported by Axios, of 119 million page views in January 2024, up from 101 million in December and 77 million in November (founder-cited analytics) (Axios).
- That was not enough. Axios argued that the premise — "that a big, generic news audience has value" — no longer held in a market where social platforms were distributing less news and advertising had shifted toward smaller, loyal audiences (Axios).
What to learn
- A large raise can hide a revenue problem for only a few months. Axios, citing documents, put 2023 revenue at about $3 million against a $50 million launch raise (Axios).
- Hiring to a mission is not the same as hiring to the revenue you have. Finkelstein later said salaries were 82% of spending (Axios).
- Projections that start at $100 million and then fall are a warning, not a plan (Axios).
- If you wait for a rescue round, you may have nothing left for severance. Axios reported that the final staff got none, after an earlier January layoff did include severance (Axios; Axios).
Risks and what didn't work
- The $3 million revenue figure comes from financial documents seen by Axios, not from a public audited filing (Axios).
- Finkelstein's claim that $20 million more would have made the site profitable by August is his own, made after the shutdown (Axios).
- Page-view figures are founder-cited Google Analytics data reported by Axios, not an independent audit (Axios).
- The business model was advertising at scale in a worse market for generic news traffic. That is the core failure Axios identified, independent of any one fundraising weekend (Axios).
FAQ
Short answers drawn from the sections above.
What is The Messenger?
The Messenger was a digital news startup founded by Jimmy Finkelstein. Axios wrote that he launched it in 2023, "two years after he sold The Hill — a Beltway-based print and digital publication co-founded by Finkelstein's father in 1994 — to Nexstar for $130 million" (Axios).
Why did The Messenger work?
- The founder had already sold a political-news business. The Hill sale to Nexstar for $130 million made it possible to raise a large seed and hire quickly (Axios).
- The site did get traffic at the end. Finkelstein cited Google Analytics figures, reported by Axios, of 119 million page views in January 2024, up from 101 million in December and 77 million in November (founder-cited analytics) (Axios).
- That was not enough. Axios argued that the premise — "that a big, generic news audience has value" — no longer held in a market where social platforms were distributing less news and advertising had shifted toward smaller, loyal audiences (Axios).
What can indie builders learn from The Messenger?
- A large raise can hide a revenue problem for only a few months. Axios, citing documents, put 2023 revenue at about $3 million against a $50 million launch raise (Axios).
- Hiring to a mission is not the same as hiring to the revenue you have. Finkelstein later said salaries were 82% of spending (Axios).
- Projections that start at $100 million and then fall are a warning, not a plan (Axios).
- If you wait for a rescue round, you may have nothing left for severance. Axios reported that the final staff got none, after an earlier January layoff did include severance (Axios; Axios).
What didn't work for The Messenger, and what are the risks?
- The $3 million revenue figure comes from financial documents seen by Axios, not from a public audited filing (Axios).
- Finkelstein's claim that $20 million more would have made the site profitable by August is his own, made after the shutdown (Axios).
- Page-view figures are founder-cited Google Analytics data reported by Axios, not an independent audit (Axios).
- The business model was advertising at scale in a worse market for generic news traffic. That is the core failure Axios identified, independent of any one fundraising weekend (Axios).
Sources
Every link cited above, in order of first use.
- 1.The Messenger (axios.com)
- 2.$50 million (axios.com)
Related case studies
More in Other →beehiiv: from Morning Brew alumni to $32M annualized newsletter platform
Tyler Denk's newsletter platform hit $20M ARR in July 2025 and $32M annualized revenue by its fourth anniversary, with creators earning $45M+ on-platform.
Indie Hackers: acquired by Stripe, then back to $0 MRR
Indie Hackers was bought by Stripe within a year of launch and spun back out six years later. Its founders restarted as a standalone business with no revenue.
Substack: $100 million Series C after 5 million paid subscriptions
Chris Best, Hamish McKenzie, and Jairaj Sethi built a newsletter subscription platform and launched it with Sinocism in 2017. In 2025 the company said it had passed 5 million paid subscriptions and raised a $100 million Series C.