wouldit.work

Consumer apps

IRL: a $1.17B social app shut down over fake users

IRL was a group-chat and event app that raised a SoftBank-led $170 million Series C at a $1.17 billion valuation. In 2023 its board found that 95% of its reported 20 million users were bots, and the company shut down.

Product
IRL
Founder
Abraham Shafi
Launched
n/a
Model
Venture-funded consumer social app

Published · 3 min read · 3 sources

Key takeaways

  • IRL positioned itself as a Gen Z group-chat and event app and raised a SoftBank-led $170 million Series C at a $1.17 billion valuation.
  • An internal board investigation, first reported by The Information and recounted by TechCrunch, found that 95% of the app's reported 20 million users were automated or bots.
  • The company shut down in June 2023 after raising more than $200 million; its CEO had already been suspended, and the SEC had begun looking at whether securities laws were violated.

What it is

IRL was a social app for group messaging and event organizing, aimed at younger users who were using Facebook less. Its own site later said, "IRL has shut down as of June 27th at 12pm PDT" (irl.com). Shafi described it as “Facebook groups and events for the generation that doesn’t use Facebook” (TechCrunch, The Verge). It was founded by Abraham Shafi, who served as CEO until the company's board suspended him in 2023 (TechCrunch).

Timeline

  • Funding: TechCrunch wrote that IRL raised a SoftBank-led $170 million Series C at a $1.17 billion valuation, and that it had raised more than $200 million in venture capital overall.
  • 2022: The company laid off 25% of its team, "or around 25 employees," after having more than tripled headcount the year before. In a memo obtained by TechCrunch, Shafi said IRL had "more than enough cash to last well into 2024." An employee told TechCrunch the company then had more than $100 million in the bank.
  • Around the same time: Employees "started doubting Shafi's claim that the app had 20 million monthly active users," and the SEC began investigating whether IRL violated securities laws (TechCrunch).
  • April 2023: The board suspended Shafi and appointed an acting CEO (TechCrunch).
  • June 26, 2023: TechCrunch reported that an internal investigation by the board had found that 95% of the reported 20 million users were "automated or from bots" (The Information first reported the finding), and that IRL was shutting down. A company spokesperson told The Information it would return remaining capital to shareholders (TechCrunch). The Verge similarly reported that IRL had raised $200 million at over a $1 billion valuation, that a special committee of the board found 95% of the claimed 20 million users were fake, and that the board was dissolving the company. Shafi, in texts with The Verge, said: "The 95% number shocked me and many others at the company. We have not been given a basis to justify this number and believe it is wrong... [we] believed in our metrics." He also said his suspension "had nothing to do with bots" and was told it was "due to a personal expenses issue" (The Verge).

Why it worked

  • It told a story investors already wanted. A Gen Z alternative to Facebook, plus a SoftBank-led round and a unicorn valuation, is a fundable narrative even before the user numbers are proven (TechCrunch).
  • The growth claims were extreme enough to raise money. A reported 20 million users and a $1.17 billion valuation are what made IRL look like a breakout — and what later fell apart.
  • There was real cash, for a while. An employee told TechCrunch the company had more than $100 million in the bank at the 2022 layoffs, which is why a shutdown still came as a shock.

This is not a story about a product that found durable demand. It is a story about how far a consumer app can get on a metric that later failed a board investigation.

What to learn

  1. Treat spectacular user counts as a claim to verify, especially when they are the basis for a unicorn round (TechCrunch).
  2. Employees often see the problem first. Doubts about the 20 million figure showed up inside the company before the board's 95% finding was reported.
  3. "Enough cash to last into 2024" does not help if the growth story the company was funded on does not hold (TechCrunch).
  4. For a social app, bots are not a rounding error. If 95% of reported users are automated, the remaining business is a different, much smaller company.

Risks and what didn't work

  • The core metric was disputed. The board's investigation found that 95% of the reported 20 million users were "automated or from bots." Shafi told The Verge he was "shocked" by that figure, believed it was wrong, and said he and his team "believed in our metrics" (The Verge).
  • Legal risk followed the numbers. TechCrunch reported that the SEC had begun investigating possible securities-law violations (TechCrunch).
  • Funding and user figures in this article come from TechCrunch's account, including facts it attributed to The Information. They are not from IRL filings reviewed here.
  • The product is gone. When TechCrunch tried to reach Shafi and another employee, their IRL email addresses had already been disabled (TechCrunch).

FAQ

Short answers drawn from the sections above.

What is IRL?

IRL was a social app for group messaging and event organizing, aimed at younger users who were using Facebook less. Its own site later said, "IRL has shut down as of June 27th at 12pm PDT" (irl.com). Shafi described it as “Facebook groups and events for the generation that doesn’t use Facebook” (TechCrunch, The Verge). It was founded by Abraham Shafi, who served as CEO until the company's board suspended him in 2023 (TechCrunch).

Why did IRL work?

  • It told a story investors already wanted. A Gen Z alternative to Facebook, plus a SoftBank-led round and a unicorn valuation, is a fundable narrative even before the user numbers are proven (TechCrunch).
  • The growth claims were extreme enough to raise money. A reported 20 million users and a $1.17 billion valuation are what made IRL look like a breakout — and what later fell apart.
  • There was real cash, for a while. An employee told TechCrunch the company had more than $100 million in the bank at the 2022 layoffs, which is why a shutdown still came as a shock.

What can indie builders learn from IRL?

  1. Treat spectacular user counts as a claim to verify, especially when they are the basis for a unicorn round (TechCrunch).
  2. Employees often see the problem first. Doubts about the 20 million figure showed up inside the company before the board's 95% finding was reported.
  3. "Enough cash to last into 2024" does not help if the growth story the company was funded on does not hold (TechCrunch).
  4. For a social app, bots are not a rounding error. If 95% of reported users are automated, the remaining business is a different, much smaller company.

What didn't work for IRL, and what are the risks?

  • The core metric was disputed. The board's investigation found that 95% of the reported 20 million users were "automated or from bots." Shafi told The Verge he was "shocked" by that figure, believed it was wrong, and said he and his team "believed in our metrics" (The Verge).
  • Legal risk followed the numbers. TechCrunch reported that the SEC had begun investigating possible securities-law violations (TechCrunch).
  • Funding and user figures in this article come from TechCrunch's account, including facts it attributed to The Information. They are not from IRL filings reviewed here.
  • The product is gone. When TechCrunch tried to reach Shafi and another employee, their IRL email addresses had already been disabled (TechCrunch).

Sources

Every link cited above, in order of first use.

  1. 1.IRL (irl.com)
  2. 2.TechCrunch (techcrunch.com)
  3. 3.The Verge (theverge.com)

Related case studies

More in Consumer apps →