wouldit.work

Consumer apps

Vine: six-second loops, a reported $30M acquisition, and a shutdown four years later

Vine let people share six-second looping videos and created a generation of internet stars. Twitter bought it before launch, then discontinued the app in 2016 after it fell behind Snapchat and Instagram.

Product
Vine
Founder
Rus Yusupov and two co-founders
Launched
2013
Model
Free, ad-supported parent (Twitter)

Published · 2 min read · 2 sources

Key takeaways

  • Twitter acquired Vine in 2012, before its official launch, for a reported $30 million.
  • On 27 October 2016, the same day Twitter announced cutting 9% of its workforce, it said it would discontinue the Vine mobile app.
  • Analysts said Vine could not keep pace with short video on Snapchat, Instagram and Facebook; co-founder Rus Yusupov tweeted: 'Don't sell your company!'

What it is

Vine let people share six-second video clips that played on a loop (BBC News). It paired the 140-character idea of a tight constraint with video, as one analyst put it (BBC News).

Timeline

  • 2012: Twitter acquires Vine before its official launch, for a reported $30 million (BBC News).
  • 2013: Vine launches (BBC News).
  • 27 October 2016: Twitter says it will discontinue the Vine mobile app "in the coming months", on the same day it announces a 9% cut to its workforce (BBC News). The website stays online so old Vines remain watchable (BBC News). Twitter is laying off roughly 350 people as part of a restructuring to cut costs and refocus on its core app (Vox).

Why it worked

  • A strong constraint. "Twitter was all about setting a constraint on communication - 140 characters - and with Vine it tried to do the same to video," said analyst Ian Fogg (BBC News).
  • A creator culture. Vine had "a dedicated fan base" and "many Vine celebrities" (BBC News).

What to learn

  1. A format is not a moat. "Vine didn't keep pace with the innovation from Snapchat, Facebook and other players in the market," Fogg said (BBC News).
  2. Watch where your content is consumed. The BBC noted you were "almost as likely to see a Vine re-shared on Facebook than you are to see it on Vine itself" (BBC News).
  3. Inside a bigger company, a side app competes with the parent's own features. Twitter had built video into its main app and launched Periscope (BBC News).

Risks and what didn't work

  • Lost to bigger platforms. The BBC's Dave Lee wrote that Vine "just couldn't compete with short video on Snapchat and Instagram" (BBC News).
  • Cost cutting at the parent. With Twitter shedding staff, "there really is no justification for a separate app" (BBC News).
  • No revenue and no growth. Vox reported Vine "was never a revenue driver for the company, and it was no longer growing", and many top executives had left that spring and summer (Vox).
  • No official reason. Twitter did not give a reason for the closure (BBC News).

FAQ

Short answers drawn from the sections above.

What is Vine?

Vine let people share six-second video clips that played on a loop (BBC News). It paired the 140-character idea of a tight constraint with video, as one analyst put it (BBC News).

Why did Vine work?

  • A strong constraint. "Twitter was all about setting a constraint on communication - 140 characters - and with Vine it tried to do the same to video," said analyst Ian Fogg (BBC News).
  • A creator culture. Vine had "a dedicated fan base" and "many Vine celebrities" (BBC News).

What can indie builders learn from Vine?

  1. A format is not a moat. "Vine didn't keep pace with the innovation from Snapchat, Facebook and other players in the market," Fogg said (BBC News).
  2. Watch where your content is consumed. The BBC noted you were "almost as likely to see a Vine re-shared on Facebook than you are to see it on Vine itself" (BBC News).
  3. Inside a bigger company, a side app competes with the parent's own features. Twitter had built video into its main app and launched Periscope (BBC News).

What didn't work for Vine, and what are the risks?

  • Lost to bigger platforms. The BBC's Dave Lee wrote that Vine "just couldn't compete with short video on Snapchat and Instagram" (BBC News).
  • Cost cutting at the parent. With Twitter shedding staff, "there really is no justification for a separate app" (BBC News).
  • No revenue and no growth. Vox reported Vine "was never a revenue driver for the company, and it was no longer growing", and many top executives had left that spring and summer (Vox).
  • No official reason. Twitter did not give a reason for the closure (BBC News).

Sources

Every link cited above, in order of first use.

  1. 1.BBC News (bbc.com)
  2. 2.Vox (vox.com)

Related case studies

More in Consumer apps →