wouldit.work

Consumer apps

Mailbox: a million-person waitlist, a Dropbox acquisition, and a shutdown three years later

Mailbox was a gesture-based mobile email app that launched in 2013 with a waitlist of more than a million people. Inside Dropbox it stopped getting updates, slid down the app charts and was shut down in February 2016.

Product
Mailbox
Founder
Gentry Underwood and Scott Cannon
Launched
2013
Model
Free app (owned by Dropbox)

Published · 2 min read · 2 sources

Key takeaways

  • Mailbox launched in 2013 with huge hype and more than a million people on its waiting list.
  • By December 2015 it had not been updated since July and ranked 233 in the US productivity category; Dropbox shut it down on 26 February 2016.
  • Dropbox said it was refocusing on collaboration, while TechCrunch's headline put it more bluntly: 'Failing To Find Users'.

What it is

Mailbox was an email client that sat on top of Gmail, with a simple interface that used gestures to quickly dismiss or archive messages, initially on mobile (TechCrunch). Dropbox owned it until the shutdown (TechCrunch).

Timeline

  • 2013: Mailbox launches "with a huge amount of hype", helped by the scarcity of a waiting list of more than a million people (TechCrunch).
  • 2013: Dropbox acquires Mailbox "because we believed in the way it was making mobile email better" (Dropbox).
  • July 2015: Last update to the app before the shutdown announcement (TechCrunch).
  • 7 December 2015: Dropbox co-founders Drew Houston and Arash Ferdowsi announce Mailbox and Carousel will close (TechCrunch). At the time Mailbox ranks 233 in the US iTunes productivity category (TechCrunch).
  • 26 February 2016: Mailbox shuts down (TechCrunch).

Why it worked

  • A fresh interaction. Swipe gestures to clear an inbox were "at the time, unique" (TechCrunch).
  • Scarcity marketing. The waitlist of more than a million people drove much of the launch buzz (TechCrunch).
  • Low switching cost. Because it sat on Gmail, users kept their email where it was (TechCrunch).

What to learn

  1. A waitlist creates a launch, not a habit. TechCrunch, citing App Annie, said neither Mailbox nor Carousel saw "anything like sustained popularity beyond their initial releases" (TechCrunch).
  2. A great interaction can be copied. Mailbox's edge was its gesture interface, and nothing protected it (TechCrunch).
  3. After an acquisition, your roadmap belongs to the buyer. Dropbox said it would use "what we've learned from Mailbox" to build collaboration features like Dropbox Paper (Dropbox). Dropbox chose "collaboration and simplifying the way people work together" over Mailbox (TechCrunch).

Risks and what didn't work

  • Neglect before the end. Updates stopped in July and support questions went unanswered, even as support staff told a user that morning that Mailbox "hasn't been abandoned" (TechCrunch).
  • Built on someone else's platform. As a Gmail client, Mailbox depended on another company's service (TechCrunch).
  • Founders moved on. Co-founder Gentry Underwood had already left Dropbox, and Scott Cannon stayed only briefly as an advisor (TechCrunch).

FAQ

Short answers drawn from the sections above.

What is Mailbox?

Mailbox was an email client that sat on top of Gmail, with a simple interface that used gestures to quickly dismiss or archive messages, initially on mobile (TechCrunch). Dropbox owned it until the shutdown (TechCrunch).

Why did Mailbox work?

  • A fresh interaction. Swipe gestures to clear an inbox were "at the time, unique" (TechCrunch).
  • Scarcity marketing. The waitlist of more than a million people drove much of the launch buzz (TechCrunch).
  • Low switching cost. Because it sat on Gmail, users kept their email where it was (TechCrunch).

What can indie builders learn from Mailbox?

  1. A waitlist creates a launch, not a habit. TechCrunch, citing App Annie, said neither Mailbox nor Carousel saw "anything like sustained popularity beyond their initial releases" (TechCrunch).
  2. A great interaction can be copied. Mailbox's edge was its gesture interface, and nothing protected it (TechCrunch).
  3. After an acquisition, your roadmap belongs to the buyer. Dropbox said it would use "what we've learned from Mailbox" to build collaboration features like Dropbox Paper (Dropbox). Dropbox chose "collaboration and simplifying the way people work together" over Mailbox (TechCrunch).

What didn't work for Mailbox, and what are the risks?

  • Neglect before the end. Updates stopped in July and support questions went unanswered, even as support staff told a user that morning that Mailbox "hasn't been abandoned" (TechCrunch).
  • Built on someone else's platform. As a Gmail client, Mailbox depended on another company's service (TechCrunch).
  • Founders moved on. Co-founder Gentry Underwood had already left Dropbox, and Scott Cannon stayed only briefly as an advisor (TechCrunch).

Sources

Every link cited above, in order of first use.

  1. 1.TechCrunch (techcrunch.com)
  2. 2.Dropbox (blog.dropbox.com)

Related case studies

More in Consumer apps →